Skip to main content
article icon

Clint and me: Mossbourne head says school leaders are 'lone heroes'

News | Published in TES Newspaper on 18 February, 2011 | By: Irena Barker

Wilshaw shoots from the hip as he urges others to follow his tough- guy role model

Clint Eastwood’s characters in Westerns are “a model for 21st-century school leadership”, a celebrated headteacher has said, calling for school leaders to become “the lone warrior, fighting for righteousness”.

Sir Michael Wilshaw, head of Mossbourne Community Academy, in Hackney, often feted by education secretary Michael Gove, said heads should reject new trends towards shared or “distributed” leadership and needed “more ego”.

He said schools needed powerful heads who were “entrepreneurs and empire builders” and unafraid to upset staff if it is in the long-term interests of the school.

Sir Michael, who has taken on a series of advisory roles for the Government, told the 100 Group conference of leading state and private school heads in London last week: “Take that scene in Pale Rider when the baddies are shooting up the town, the mists dissipate and Clint is there.

“Being a headteacher is all about being the lone warrior, fighting for righteousness, fighting the good fight, as powerful as any chief executive.

“I’m not that bothered about distributed leadership; I would never use it; I don’t think Clint would either. We need headteachers with ego. You see heads who don’t use ‘I’ and use ‘we’ instead, but they should.

“We need heads who enjoy power and enjoy exercising that power.”

Sir Michael also tore into a stack of core initiatives started by the previous government, including Every Child Matters, personalised learning and the community cohesion duty.

He said schemes such as the national strategies took good staff away from schools: “Thank God (they are) being closed down,” he said.

Sir Michael’s comments will irritate many school leadership teams which have adopted the philosophy of shared or distributed leadership.

The National College, which awards the National Professional Qualification for Headship, has worked hard to debunk the myth of the “hero” or “superhead”, preferring to promote a more caring and sharing approach.

But his speech chimes with the new coalition Government’s view that schools should seek independence from local authorities and have more control over their finances.

Brian Lightman, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, hit back at Sir Michael’s Clint Eastwood call.

He told The TES: “Different schools require different styles of leadership, but schools are too complex institutions to be led by one person alone.”

Toby Salt, deputy chief executive of the National College, added: “Heads make tough decisions every day and there is no one way to be a great leader.”

He said the college trained heads “so they can be confident in their decision-making and inspire others to do the same”.

Heads at the 100 Group conference expressed concern that having too much authority in the hands of one person made schools vulnerable to abuse of power.

Sir Michael has been the darling of both the Labour and Tory parties because of his success at Mossbourne, which opened on the site of the failing Hackney Downs School in 2004.

Since taking on his role, his hardline approach to everything from uniform to detentions has been credited with achieving outstanding exam results. Ten of his pupils received offers from Cambridge University this year.

Some headteachers have claimed that Mossbourne creams off the most talented pupils, a charge that has been denied by Sir Michael, who is also director of education at the charity and academy chain Absolute Return for Kids (Ark).

SATS DISPUTE

‘BOYCOTT HEADS: MY SHAME’

Sir Michael Wilshaw has infuriated unions by saying he is “ashamed” of primary heads who took part in the key stage 2 Sats boycott last year.

Sir Michael told the 100 Group conference of leading state and independent school heads: “I felt ashamed that some of the heads opted out of Sats at KS2.”

Asked by The TES to expand on his statement, he said: “I was slightly surprised (that they took part in the boycott).

“There’s a contract you are making; you are more powerful than you have ever been but we want you to be accountable.

“Publication of exam results has been shown to be very beneficial.”

Unions, however, claim that the publication of test results and league tables is unfair and twists the curriculum towards “teaching to the test”, at the expense of other learning.

Russell Hobby, general secretary of heads’ union the NAHT, said: “Heads must be held accountable, but for the right things; it’s about schools being measured on what matters.

“I’m proud of people who would risk careers and reputations to make that happen.”


Subscribe to the magazine

as yet unrated

Comment (8)

  • Well, well well, the genius of Sir Michael Wilshaw. Is it any wonder that schools are struggling to recruit outstanding leaders when the government's pet is promoting such lunacy. And when your rare, outstanding Clint Eastwood type moves on, what becomes of your school?
    Ego, the desire for power, the absence of distributed leadership, fear?
    Is this 21st century England or North Korea?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    17:03
    18 February, 2011

    tomcassidy

  • Quote: "Being a headteacher is all about being the lone warrior, fighting for righteousness, fighting the good fight, as powerful as any chief executive. I'm not that bothered about distributed leadership; I would never use it; I don't think Clint would either. We need headteachers with ego. You see heads who don't use 'I' and use 'we' instead, but they should. We need heads who enjoy power and enjoy exercising that power."

    Sir Michael Wilshaw would be well advised to have a look at what generally happens to dictators throughout history; Hitler, Mussolini and even a certain Mubarak!

    Tahrir Square here I come!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    16:25
    19 February, 2011

    Brooke Bond

  • As a middle aged male headteacher in a secondary school I must tell the world that the last thing education needs is more middle aged male headteachers with egos. Bring on a little modesty and some people who aren't trying to act out adolescent fantasies. Clint Eastwood ? This bloke should listen to himself.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    10:13
    22 February, 2011

    tommysmith4

  • Quote: "Being a dictator is all about being the lone warrior, fighting for righteousness, fighting the good fight, as powerful as any chief executive. I'm not that bothered about distributed leadership; I would never use it; I don't think Clint would either. We need dictators with ego. You see dictators who don't use 'I' and use 'we' instead, but they should. We need dictators who enjoy power and enjoy exercising that power." Worthy of Colonel Gaddafi?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    0:59
    24 February, 2011

    tomcassidy

  • There is no doubt that the maverick always enjoys a degree of success and the lone warrior has his moment. However I am reminded of the maxim "behind every good man is the person who put him there". I bet there are a host of good leaders with this man in his school who could tell a different story. No man is an island, you can only rule with concensus. He may have had vision and the power to achieve change in his school but he does not know all the answers and he certainly didn't achieve all that success on his own. Oh, and another maxim he might want to consider.. pride comes before a fall!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    14:29
    18 March, 2011

    simpsonr

  • Absolute power corrupts absolutely - and quite right too. Would hate to think anyone in the management of education could be accused of having any hint of good business management. Good god - whatever next? Find me a head without an employement tribunal in the making and i will show you how to make water out or wine!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    18:39
    15 July, 2011

    sats

  • I am pleased that this maverick had the guts to at least debunk so many myths in one blow. Absolutely refreshing even if the Pale Rider metaphor was more fun than reality. This guy has loads of power BUT I bet he exercises it with care and I bet he relies on others to also lead...but the nonsense of leadership espoused by Toby salt and others needed a good blast.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    21:25
    28 August, 2011

    Peter Barnard

  • Whilst I agree with Sir Michael Wilshaw's emphasis on the Headteacher as a leader who should not be afraid to take difficult decisions or someone who is prepared to put their head above the parapet, I would question his underlying assumption that somehow, the rest of the teaching staff within a school would be opposed to it’s long-term success by virtue of their lowly positions. Surely it is in the interest of all staff to have high standards of behaviour and for the school to be academically successful. Sir Michael's vision of “the lone warrior, fighting for righteousness” ,reveals a certain insecurity and paranoia and a fundamental distrust of his staff. His choice of the Clint Eastwood, 'Pale Rider' character reveals him to be not a man of education and culture, but rather somewhat of a Philistine. With his diplomatic skills Sir Michael smacks more of Calamity Jane than Pale Rider.


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    16:02
    10 November, 2011

    FintanLogue

Add your comment

Subscribe to the magazine

Related articles

More Articles

Join TES for free now

Join TES for free now

Four great reasons to join today...

1. Be part of the largest network of teachers in the world – over 2m members
2. Download over 600,000 free teaching resources
3. Get a personalized email of the most relevant resources for you delivered to your inbox.
4. Find out first about the latest jobs in education

Images